Failed payment recovery on Shopify means retrying a declined subscription charge on a schedule, emailing the customer a way to fix their card, and deciding what happens to the subscription if every retry fails. Recurly puts involuntary churn (failed payments) at roughly 20-40% of all subscription churn, so this is revenue you lose without the customer ever choosing to leave.
Dunning is the name for that process: automatic retries, customer notifications and a final action. Timing matters. Recurly reports that about 90% of recovered failed payments are recovered within the first 10 days, and that smarter retry strategies add 10-20 percentage points of recovery over basic retries. Below we cover why payments fail, how to build a sequence, and exactly how to set it up in SubzWallet.
Why subscription payments fail on Shopify
Payment failures happen for specific, predictable reasons. Understanding the cause helps you choose the right recovery approach.
- Expired cards: Credit and debit cards expire every few years, and customers rarely update their payment details proactively.
- Insufficient funds: The customer's account does not have enough money at the time of the charge. This is often temporary and resolves within a few days.
- Bank declines: The issuing bank blocks the transaction due to fraud detection, spending limits, or account restrictions.
- Card network errors: Temporary processing failures between Visa/Mastercard networks and the issuing bank. Usually resolve on retry.
- Lost or stolen cards: The customer reported the card as lost or stolen, and the old card number no longer works.
- Incorrect billing info: The billing address or CVV on file no longer matches what the bank has. This triggers a soft decline.
Shopify Payments automatic card updater
If you use Shopify Payments, there is help for expired cards. Visa and Mastercard operate card updater services that push new card numbers to merchants when a customer receives a replacement card, and Shopify Payments participates in these programs.
This means that when a customer gets a new card from their bank, the updated details often arrive automatically, with no action from the customer. It does not catch every case: not every issuing bank takes part, so some replaced cards still fail at the next renewal.
Even with automatic card updating, you still need a dunning sequence for failures that slip through. The card updater is a first line of defense, not a complete solution.
How to build a dunning sequence
A dunning sequence combines automatic payment retries with customer notifications. The goal is to recover the payment before the subscription lapses. Here is a proven sequence:
- Day 0 (payment fails): Send the customer an email explaining the failure and asking them to update their payment method, with a direct link to do it.
- Day 3: Retry the payment. If it fails again, send a second email that says when the next attempt will happen.
- Day 6: Retry again. Send a reminder by email, or by SMS from your own SMS tool if the customer opted in.
- Day 9: Final retry. Send a "final attempt" email that says clearly what happens next (the order is skipped, or the subscription is paused or cancelled).
- After the last retry: Apply the final action. Pause is usually the gentlest choice, because the customer can resume without signing up again.
The retry timing matters. Do not retry every day. Card issues often resolve within a few days (for example, when a paycheck deposits or a bank lifts a temporary hold). Spacing retries 2-3 days apart gives the underlying issue time to resolve, and keeps most attempts inside the first 10 days, where Recurly finds most recoveries happen.
How to set up failed payment recovery in SubzWallet
In SubzWallet, failed payment recovery is set on one screen, Settings → Dunning, and runs on Shopify's native subscription contracts, so the customer's saved card stays in Shopify. Here is the setup, step by step:
- Open Settings → Dunning in the SubzWallet admin. Under Payment Failures → Retry Configuration, set Retry Attempts (0-10) and Days Between Retries (1-14).
- Pick what happens After All Retries Fail: Skip billing cycle, Pause subscription or Cancel subscription. The screen itself recommends 3-5 retry attempts, 2-3 days apart, then pause.
- Under Inventory Failures → Out-of-Stock Handling, set the same three fields for renewals that fail because a product is out of stock. Those orders are kept as owed and retried. Choose a Staff Notification frequency: Immediately, Weekly or Monthly.
- Open Emails and review the three payment templates: Payment Failed (the first notice), Payment Retry (retry scheduled) and Final Attempt (last payment attempt warning). Each has its own on/off switch. Edit them in the drag-and-drop block editor, apply your store branding and send from your own domain.
- Turn on the Payment Failure Alert staff email if you want your team told about each failure.
- If you use Klaviyo, connect it in Settings. SubzWallet sends its subscription events to Klaviyo, and when Klaviyo is connected it sends the customer emails instead of the app. That is also the route for SMS reminders, since SubzWallet itself sends email only.
What the customer sees: an email in your branding that explains the payment did not go through. From the customer portal they can update their payment method, and Shopify emails them a secure link to enter the new card. Your team can also send the payment-update email from any subscription page in the admin, and every step shows up in that subscription's activity timeline.
Day to day, the Alert center lists failed and at-risk subscriptions, and its Restock needed panel shows which products are blocking renewals. The subscription list also has a Failed tab with a count. On Launch and higher plans, the Dunning tab in Analytics tracks failed-payment recovery over time.
Coming soon: a backup payment method that charges another saved card when the main one fails. If you are comparing apps, see our page on dunning management for Shopify; for other apps' plans, check their current pricing pages, since tiers change often.
Email templates that recover payments
Dunning emails need to be clear, urgent, and helpful. Here are the principles that work:
- Subject line: Be direct. "Your payment for [Product Name] failed" outperforms vague subjects like "Action required on your account."
- First sentence: State what happened. "We tried to process your subscription payment of $34.99, but your card was declined."
- Call to action: One button that says "Update Payment Method" linking directly to the payment update page. Do not make them log in and navigate.
- Deadline: Tell them when the next retry happens or when the subscription will pause. "We will try again on March 15. If the payment does not go through, your subscription will be paused on March 17."
- Tone: Helpful, not threatening. The customer did not do anything wrong. Their card just failed.
Keep every dunning email under 100 words. Long emails get ignored when the action needed is simple.
Recovery metrics to track
Measure your dunning performance with these metrics:
- Involuntary churn rate: Percentage of active subscriptions lost to payment failures each month. Track the trend month over month rather than chasing a fixed target.
- Recovery rate: Percentage of failed payments recovered through retries and dunning emails. If it drops after you change retry settings, the change did not help.
- Time to recovery: Average number of days between the first failure and successful payment. Shorter is better. Recurly finds about 90% of recoveries land within the first 10 days.
- Email open rate on dunning messages: Usually well above your marketing emails, because the content is urgent and personal. A low open rate points to the subject line or sender.
- Payment update rate: Percentage of customers who manually update their payment info after receiving a dunning email. This tells you if your CTA and payment update page are working.
Preventing payment failures before they happen
The best dunning strategy is to prevent failures in the first place. Three tactics that reduce failure rates:
- Pre-dunning emails: Send an email 7 days before a card expires. "Your card ending in 4242 expires next month. Update it now to keep your subscription active." This catches expired cards before they cause a failure.
- Payment method diversity: Accept multiple payment methods (credit cards, debit cards, PayPal, Shop Pay). Customers with backup payment options are less likely to churn involuntarily.
- Charge timing: If you see higher failure rates on the 1st of the month (when rent and bills hit), consider shifting billing dates to the 15th. Spreading charges across the month reduces insufficient-funds declines. In SubzWallet you can also choose the hour of day renewals are billed, in Settings.
- Upcoming-order reminders: An email a few days before the charge gives customers time to update a card or skip. SubzWallet lets you set how many days before and the send hour.
See the tools behind this guide: dunning management software for Shopify.
Frequently asked questions
What percentage of subscription churn is involuntary?
Recurly puts involuntary churn, caused by payment failures rather than customer choice, at roughly 20-40% of all subscription churn.
How many times should I retry a failed subscription payment?
Three to five retries, 2-3 days apart, is a common starting point, and it is what the SubzWallet Dunning Settings screen recommends before pausing. Keep most retries inside the first 10 days, where Recurly finds about 90% of recoveries happen.
Does Shopify Payments automatically update expired cards?
Yes. Shopify Payments participates in Visa and Mastercard card updater programs. When a customer gets a new card, the updated details are often pushed to Shopify automatically. This does not cover all cards, so you still need dunning.
What is a good recovery rate for failed subscription payments?
It depends on your card mix and customers, so compare against your own baseline. Recurly reports that smarter retry strategies add 10-20 percentage points of recovery over basic retries, so retry timing and clear emails are where to look first.
Should I cancel or pause a subscription after failed payments?
Pause is usually better than cancel. A paused subscription keeps its plan and items, and the customer can resume it from the portal. In SubzWallet you choose skip, pause or cancel as the final action in Settings → Dunning.
How do I set up failed payment recovery in SubzWallet?
Open Settings → Dunning, set Retry Attempts (0-10), Days Between Retries (1-14) and the action after all retries fail (skip, pause or cancel). Then review the Payment Failed, Payment Retry and Final Attempt emails in Emails.
Stop losing subscribers to failed payments
SubzWallet retries failed charges on a schedule, keeps out-of-stock orders owed instead of lost, and shows every at-risk subscription in one alert center.
Every paid plan comes with a dedicated developer and account manager for your shop.